pf和iptables的压力测试对比---所有测试结果统计和详细数据已整理完毕

platinum

我用的也是千兆网卡，为什么单向、单线程、无规则的情况下只有不到 400Mbps？
endpoint1 和 endpoint2 都是 XP 系统，Realtek RTL8168 千兆网卡
测试机 Intel 82541 千兆网卡

endpoint1 与 endpoint2 直连可以达到 960Mbps，连上 Linux 后只有 390Mbps，网线没有问题，Linux 系统 CPU 剩余 50%，为什么这样？

cgweb

不错,写的好,关注中....

ruochen

留名关注
谢谢测试

skylove

关注。。。图片做的好漂亮，用的啥工具娃？

kevin.tan

原帖由 skylove 于 2008-3-18 18:35 发表
关注。。。图片做的好漂亮，用的啥工具娃？

上面有说是用的word，

BTW，目前还没学会在word中做这样的柱形图

hqpp

不好意思 前几天工作忙 没有时间整理数据 今天把所有测试数据都放出来
我愿意把资料和大家一起分享。











IxChariot
Summary - C:\Documents and Settings\Administrator\桌面\Tests\双机直连\双机单向5线程.tst

Console version5.40Console build level011Console product typeIxChariotFilenameC:\Documents and Settings\Administrator\桌面\Tests\双机直连\双机单向5线程.tstRun start time2008年3月16日, 2:18:44Run end time2008年3月16日, 2:25:57Elapsed time00:07:13How the test endedRan to completionNumber of pairs5


Run Options
End typeRun until any pair endsReporting typeReal-timeAutomatically poll endpointsYesPolling interval (minutes)1Stop run upon initialization failureYesConnect timeout during test (minutes)0Stop test after this many running pairs fail1Collect endpoint CPU utilizationNoValidate data upon receiptNoUse a new seed for random variables on every runYes


Test Execution (Endpoint 1 to Endpoint 2)
Group/ PairEndpoint 1Endpoint 2Network ProtocolService QualityScript/Stream NameAll PairsPair 161.150.4.261.150.4.1TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 261.150.4.261.150.4.1TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 361.150.4.261.150.4.1TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 461.150.4.261.150.4.1TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 561.150.4.261.150.4.1TCPThroughput-big.scr

Throughput
Group/ PairAverage (Mbps)Minimum (Mbps)Maximum (Mbps)Throughput 95% Confidence IntervalMeasured Time (secs)Relative PrecisionAll Pairs917.213176.757188.457Pair 1184.818178.094187.9260.356428.5300.193Pair 2184.743177.896187.8380.340428.7040.184Pair 3184.752177.699187.7050.361428.6830.195Pair 4184.943176.757188.4570.372432.5650.201Pair 5184.850176.913188.1910.385428.4560.208Totals:917.213176.757188.457

Transaction Rate
Group/ PairTransaction Rate AverageTransaction Rate MinimumTransaction Rate MaximumTransaction Rate 95% Confidence IntervalMeasured Time (secs)Relative PrecisionAll Pairs1.1550.2210.236Pair 10.2310.2230.2350.000428.5300.193Pair 20.2310.2220.2350.000428.7040.184Pair 30.2310.2220.2350.000428.6830.195Pair 40.2310.2210.2360.000432.5650.201Pair 50.2310.2210.2350.000428.4560.208Totals:1.1550.2210.236

Response Time
Group/ PairResponse Time AverageResponse Time MinimumResponse Time MaximumResponse Time 95% Confidence IntervalMeasured Time (secs)Relative PrecisionAll Pairs4.3294.2454.526Pair 14.3294.2574.4920.008428.5300.193Pair 24.3304.2594.4970.008428.7040.184Pair 34.3304.2624.5020.008428.6830.195Pair 44.3264.2454.5260.009432.5650.201Pair 54.3284.2514.5220.009428.4560.208Totals:4.3294.2454.526

[ 本帖最后由 hqpp 于 2008-3-24 09:35 编辑 ]

HH106

关注,支持LZ,真的很不错

hqpp

IxChariot

Summary - C:\Documents and Settings\Administrator\桌面\Tests\双机直连\双机单向10线程.tst
Console version5.40Console build level011Console product typeIxChariotFilenameC:\Documents and Settings\Administrator\桌面\Tests\双机直连\双机单向10线程.tstRun start time2008年3月15日, 23:35:10Run end time2008年3月15日, 23:49:35Elapsed time00:14:25How the test endedRan to completionNumber of pairs10

Run Options
End typeRun until any pair endsReporting typeReal-timeAutomatically poll endpointsYesPolling interval (minutes)1Stop run upon initialization failureYesConnect timeout during test (minutes)0Stop test after this many running pairs fail1Collect endpoint CPU utilizationNoValidate data upon receiptNoUse a new seed for random variables on every runYes

Test Execution (Endpoint 1 to Endpoint 2)
Group/ PairEndpoint 1Endpoint 2Network ProtocolService QualityScript/Stream NameAll PairsPair 161.150.4.261.150.4.1TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 261.150.4.261.150.4.1TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 361.150.4.261.150.4.1TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 461.150.4.261.150.4.1TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 561.150.4.261.150.4.1TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 661.150.4.261.150.4.1TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 761.150.4.261.150.4.1TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 861.150.4.261.150.4.1TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 961.150.4.261.150.4.1TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 1061.150.4.261.150.4.1TCPThroughput-big.scr

Throughput
Group/ PairAverage (Mbps)Minimum (Mbps)Maximum (Mbps)Throughput 95% Confidence IntervalMeasured Time (secs)Relative PrecisionAll Pairs917.25672.176110.773Pair 192.29784.95394.1840.213858.1020.231Pair 292.50190.355109.3940.324856.2100.350Pair 392.41590.66293.9740.122857.0050.133Pair 492.24581.79194.0070.278858.5860.301Pair 592.46290.693104.0450.255856.5660.276Pair 692.31687.72993.9410.162857.9240.175Pair 792.40390.60093.7760.122857.1150.132Pair 892.39690.27393.7760.130857.1790.141Pair 992.56590.324110.7730.334864.2600.361Pair 1092.17972.17694.1950.534859.1960.579Totals:917.25672.176110.773


Transaction Rate
Group/ PairTransaction Rate AverageTransaction Rate MinimumTransaction Rate MaximumTransaction Rate 95% Confidence IntervalMeasured Time (secs)Relative PrecisionAll Pairs1.1550.0900.138Pair 10.1150.1060.1180.000858.1020.231Pair 20.1160.1130.1370.000856.2100.350Pair 30.1160.1130.1170.000857.0050.133Pair 40.1150.1020.1180.000858.5860.301Pair 50.1160.1130.1300.000856.5660.276Pair 60.1150.1100.1170.000857.9240.175Pair 70.1160.1130.1170.000857.1150.132Pair 80.1150.1130.1170.000857.1790.141Pair 90.1160.1130.1380.000864.2600.361Pair 100.1150.0900.1180.001859.1960.579Totals:1.1550.0900.138


Response Time
Group/ PairResponse Time AverageResponse Time MinimumResponse Time MaximumResponse Time 95% Confidence IntervalMeasured Time (secs)Relative PrecisionAll Pairs8.6607.22211.084Pair 18.6688.4949.4170.020858.1020.231Pair 28.6497.3138.8540.030856.2100.350Pair 38.6578.5138.8240.011857.0050.133Pair 48.6738.5109.7810.026858.5860.301Pair 58.6527.6898.8210.024856.5660.276Pair 68.6668.5169.1190.015857.9240.175Pair 78.6588.5318.8300.011857.1150.132Pair 88.6588.5318.8620.012857.1790.141Pair 98.6437.2228.8570.031864.2600.361Pair 108.6798.49311.0840.050859.1960.579Totals:8.6607.22211.084





IxChariot
Summary - C:\Documents and Settings\Administrator\桌面\Tests\双机直连\双机双向各5线程.tst
Console version5.40Console build level011Console product typeIxChariotFilenameC:\Documents and Settings\Administrator\桌面\Tests\双机直连\双机双向各5线程.tstRun start time2008年3月16日, 0:01:03Run end time2008年3月16日, 0:08:33Elapsed time00:07:30How the test endedRan to completionNumber of pairs10


Run Options
End typeRun until any pair endsReporting typeReal-timeAutomatically poll endpointsYesPolling interval (minutes)1Stop run upon initialization failureYesConnect timeout during test (minutes)0Stop test after this many running pairs fail1Collect endpoint CPU utilizationNoValidate data upon receiptNoUse a new seed for random variables on every runYes


Test Execution (Endpoint 1 to Endpoint 2)
Group/ PairEndpoint 1Endpoint 2Network ProtocolService QualityScript/Stream NameAll PairsPair 161.150.4.261.150.4.1TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 261.150.4.261.150.4.1TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 361.150.4.261.150.4.1TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 461.150.4.261.150.41TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 561.150.4.261.150.4.1TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 661.150.4.161.150.4.2TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 761.150.4.161.150.4.2TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 861.150.4.161.150.4.2TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 961.150.4.161.150.4.2TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 1061.150.4.161.150.4.2TCPThroughput-big.scr

Throughput
Group/ PairAverage (Mbps)Minimum (Mbps)Maximum (Mbps)Throughput 95% Confidence IntervalMeasured Time (secs)Relative PrecisionAll Pairs1,724.06581.858226.757Pair 1174.72783.412192.4935.743448.7013.287Pair 2177.67683.796190.7034.285445.7552.412Pair 3178.12983.630191.3884.279449.1132.402Pair 4177.72882.645226.7574.453445.6252.506Pair 5174.92981.858205.2337.069448.1814.041Pair 6170.233137.315187.3541.891446.4461.111Pair 7169.535133.534185.6581.948448.2841.149Pair 8169.383138.002183.9931.887443.9641.114Pair 9171.157135.800181.9421.968444.0361.150Pair 10171.043137.057183.9501.999444.3321.169Totals:1,724.06581.858226.757

Transaction Rate
Group/ PairTransaction Rate AverageTransaction Rate MinimumTransaction Rate MaximumTransaction Rate 95% Confidence IntervalMeasured Time (secs)Relative PrecisionAll Pairs2.1680.1020.283Pair 10.2180.1040.2410.007448.7013.287Pair 20.2220.1050.2380.005445.7552.412Pair 30.2230.1050.2390.005449.1132.402Pair 40.2220.1030.2830.006445.6252.506Pair 50.2190.1020.2570.009448.1814.041Pair 60.2130.1720.2340.002446.4461.111Pair 70.2120.1670.2320.002448.2841.149Pair 80.2120.1730.2300.002443.9641.114Pair 90.2140.1700.2270.002444.0361.150Pair 100.2140.1710.2300.002444.3321.169Totals:2.1680.1020.283

Response Time
Group/ PairResponse Time AverageResponse Time MinimumResponse Time MaximumResponse Time 95% Confidence IntervalMeasured Time (secs)Relative PrecisionAll Pairs4.6143.5289.773Pair 14.5794.1569.5910.150448.7013.287Pair 24.5034.1959.5470.109445.7552.412Pair 34.4914.1809.5660.108449.1132.402Pair 44.5013.5289.6800.113445.6252.506Pair 54.5733.8989.7730.185448.1814.041Pair 64.6994.2705.8260.052446.4461.111Pair 74.7194.3095.9910.054448.2841.149Pair 84.7234.3485.7970.053443.9641.114Pair 94.6744.3975.8910.054444.0361.150Pair 104.6774.3495.8370.055444.3321.169Totals:4.6143.5289.773
[/table]

[ 本帖最后由 hqpp 于 2008-3-24 09:37 编辑 ]

hqpp

IxChariot
Summary - C:\Documents and Settings\Administrator\桌面\Tests\windows\windows单向5线程.tst
Console version5.40Console build level011Console product typeIxChariotFilenameC:\Documents and Settings\Administrator\桌面\Tests\windows\windows单向5线程.tstRun start time2008年3月16日, 7:59:57Run end time2008年3月16日, 8:10:50Elapsed time00:10:53How the test endedRan to completionNumber of pairs5


Run Options
End typeRun until any pair endsReporting typeReal-timeAutomatically poll endpointsYesPolling interval (minutes)1Stop run upon initialization failureYesConnect timeout during test (minutes)0Stop test after this many running pairs fail1Collect endpoint CPU utilizationNoValidate data upon receiptNoUse a new seed for random variables on every runYes


Test Execution (Endpoint 1 to Endpoint 2)
Group/ PairEndpoint 1Endpoint 2Network ProtocolService QualityScript/Stream NameAll PairsPair 1192.168.0.210.0.0.2TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 2192.168.0.210.0.0.2TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 3192.168.0.210.0.0.2TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 4192.168.0.210.0.0.2TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 5192.168.0.210.0.0.2TCPThroughput-big.scr

Throughput
Group/ PairAverage (Mbps)Minimum (Mbps)Maximum (Mbps)Throughput 95% Confidence IntervalMeasured Time (secs)Relative PrecisionAll Pairs608.128105.263131.752Pair 1122.265105.263130.0810.534647.7730.437Pair 2122.511112.565130.2300.392646.4700.320Pair 3122.125110.895125.1760.458648.5160.375Pair 4122.618113.154131.7520.409652.4320.334Pair 5122.612118.747127.7340.327645.9380.266Totals:608.128105.263131.752

Transaction Rate
Group/ PairTransaction Rate AverageTransaction Rate MinimumTransaction Rate MaximumTransaction Rate 95% Confidence IntervalMeasured Time (secs)Relative PrecisionAll Pairs0.7650.1320.165Pair 10.1530.1320.1630.001647.7730.437Pair 20.1530.1410.1630.000646.4700.320Pair 30.1530.1390.1560.001648.5160.375Pair 40.1530.1410.1650.001652.4320.334Pair 50.1530.1480.1600.000645.9380.266Totals:0.7650.1320.165

Response Time
Group/ PairResponse Time AverageResponse Time MinimumResponse Time MaximumResponse Time 95% Confidence IntervalMeasured Time (secs)Relative PrecisionAll Pairs6.5356.0727.600Pair 16.5436.1507.6000.029647.7730.437Pair 26.5306.1437.1070.021646.4700.320Pair 36.5516.3917.2140.025648.5160.375Pair 46.5246.0727.0700.022652.4320.334Pair 56.5256.2636.7370.017645.9380.266Totals:6.5356.0727.600
[/table]
IxChariot

Summary - C:\Documents and Settings\Administrator\桌面\Tests\windows\windows双向各5线程.tst
Console version5.40Console build level011Console product typeIxChariotFilenameC:\Documents and Settings\Administrator\桌面\Tests\windows\windows双向各5线程.tstRun start time2008年3月16日, 8:16:37Run end time2008年3月16日, 8:34:32Elapsed time00:17:55How the test endedRan to completionNumber of pairs10

Run Options
End typeRun until any pair endsReporting typeReal-timeAutomatically poll endpointsYesPolling interval (minutes)1Stop run upon initialization failureYesConnect timeout during test (minutes)0Stop test after this many running pairs fail1Collect endpoint CPU utilizationNoValidate data upon receiptNoUse a new seed for random variables on every runYes

Test Execution (Endpoint 1 to Endpoint 2)
Group/ PairEndpoint 1Endpoint 2Network ProtocolService QualityScript/Stream NameAll PairsPair 1192.168.0.210.0.0.2TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 2192.168.0.210.0.0.2TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 3192.168.0.210.0.0.2TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 4192.168.0.210.0.0.2TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 5192.168.0.210.0.0.2TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 610.0.0.2192.168.0.2TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 710.0.0.2192.168.0.2TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 810.0.0.2192.168.0.2TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 910.0.0.2192.168.0.2TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 1010.0.0.2192.168.0.2TCPThroughput-big.scr

Throughput
Group/ PairAverage (Mbps)Minimum (Mbps)Maximum (Mbps)Throughput 95% Confidence IntervalMeasured Time (secs)Relative PrecisionAll Pairs684.65138.578134.953Pair 165.52053.46580.3941.0991,074.4831.678Pair 266.62455.24983.6301.1951,068.6821.794Pair 364.86149.40481.4661.3091,073.0562.017Pair 466.24657.73378.7941.0431,074.7781.574Pair 565.27950.62088.8001.3511,066.1872.069Pair 668.87939.131115.8582.8491,068.5394.137Pair 772.67849.346131.6663.0471,067.7174.193Pair 869.05348.957105.0142.6091,065.8493.778Pair 973.74038.578129.5133.3441,074.0494.535Pair 1074.42246.558134.9533.2221,074.9514.330Totals:684.65138.578134.953


Transaction Rate
Group/ PairTransaction Rate AverageTransaction Rate MinimumTransaction Rate MaximumTransaction Rate 95% Confidence IntervalMeasured Time (secs)Relative PrecisionAll Pairs0.8590.0480.169Pair 10.0820.0670.1000.0011,074.4831.678Pair 20.0830.0690.1050.0011,068.6821.794Pair 30.0810.0620.1020.0021,073.0562.017Pair 40.0830.0720.0980.0011,074.7781.574Pair 50.0820.0630.1110.0021,066.1872.069Pair 60.0860.0490.1450.0041,068.5394.137Pair 70.0910.0620.1650.0041,067.7174.193Pair 80.0860.0610.1310.0031,065.8493.778Pair 90.0920.0480.1620.0041,074.0494.535Pair 100.0930.0580.1690.0041,074.9514.330Totals:0.8590.0480.169


Response Time
Group/ PairResponse Time AverageResponse Time MinimumResponse Time MaximumResponse Time 95% Confidence IntervalMeasured Time (secs)Relative PrecisionAll Pairs11.6695.92820.737Pair 112.2109.95114.9630.2051,074.4831.678Pair 212.0089.56614.4800.2151,068.6821.794Pair 312.3349.82016.1930.2491,073.0562.017Pair 412.07610.15313.8570.1901,074.7781.574Pair 512.2559.00915.8040.2541,066.1872.069Pair 611.6156.90520.4440.4801,068.5394.137Pair 711.0076.07616.2120.4611,067.7174.193Pair 811.5857.61816.3410.4381,065.8493.778Pair 910.8496.17720.7370.4921,074.0494.535Pair 1010.7505.92817.1830.4651,074.9514.330Totals:11.6695.92820.737
[/table]
IxChariot

Summary - C:\Documents and Settings\Administrator\桌面\Tests\windows\windows-nat5线程.tst
Console version5.40Console build level011Console product typeIxChariotFilenameC:\Documents and Settings\Administrator\桌面\Tests\windows\windows-nat5线程.tstRun start time2008年3月16日, 8:46:18Run end time2008年3月16日, 8:57:29Elapsed time00:11:11How the test endedRan to completionNumber of pairs5

Run Options
End typeRun until any pair endsReporting typeReal-timeAutomatically poll endpointsYesPolling interval (minutes)1Stop run upon initialization failureYesConnect timeout during test (minutes)0Stop test after this many running pairs fail1Collect endpoint CPU utilizationNoValidate data upon receiptNoUse a new seed for random variables on every runYes

Test Execution (Endpoint 1 to Endpoint 2)
Group/ PairEndpoint 1Endpoint 2Network ProtocolService QualityScript/Stream NameAll PairsPair 110.0.0.2192.168.0.2TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 210.0.0.2192.168.0.2TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 310.0.0.2192.168.0.2TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 410.0.0.2192.168.0.2TCPThroughput-big.scrPair 510.0.0.2192.168.0.2TCPThroughput-big.scr

Throughput
Group/ PairAverage (Mbps)Minimum (Mbps)Maximum (Mbps)Throughput 95% Confidence IntervalMeasured Time (secs)Relative PrecisionAll Pairs591.411114.058123.210Pair 1118.852114.058122.4360.400666.3740.337Pair 2119.075115.174122.4550.335665.1290.282Pair 3119.148114.220122.6990.345664.7180.290Pair 4119.246114.712123.2100.299670.8820.251Pair 5118.884114.877122.6990.342666.1930.288Totals:591.411114.058123.210


Transaction Rate
Group/ PairTransaction Rate AverageTransaction Rate MinimumTransaction Rate MaximumTransaction Rate 95% Confidence IntervalMeasured Time (secs)Relative PrecisionAll Pairs0.7440.1430.154Pair 10.1490.1430.1530.000666.3740.337Pair 20.1490.1440.1530.000665.1290.282Pair 30.1490.1430.1530.000664.7180.290Pair 40.1490.1430.1540.000670.8820.251Pair 50.1490.1440.1530.000666.1930.288Totals:0.7440.1430.154


Response Time
Group/ PairResponse Time AverageResponse Time MinimumResponse Time MaximumResponse Time 95% Confidence IntervalMeasured Time (secs)Relative PrecisionAll Pairs6.7206.4937.014Pair 16.7316.5347.0140.023666.3740.337Pair 26.7186.5336.9460.019665.1290.282Pair 36.7146.5207.0040.019664.7180.290Pair 46.7096.4936.9740.017670.8820.251Pair 56.7296.5206.9640.019666.1930.288Totals:6.7206.4937.014
[/table]

[ 本帖最后由 hqpp 于 2008-3-20 09:57 编辑 ]

shdnzwy

呵呵，好详细，学习…………